Skip to main content

Turkle & Wesch

In Turkle's article "The Flight From Conversation", she shares her perspective on the technological universe that we live in today. She discusses that in our current society, we have sacrificed conversation with each other for simple connection (in the form of our communicative technologies). Though we are all connected together through our cellphones, we are not interacting in the same ways we have in the past. This has left us in a 'Goldilocks' zone according to Turkle, in which we use our technology in order to not be too close and not too far from others. In this zone of disconnection, we can be left feeling alone, with our technologies acting as a crutch we use to fend off the feelings of loneliness while only continuing the problem. She ends her article with a quote that succinctly summarizes her stance on new technologies, "If we are unable to be alone, we are far more likely to be lonely".
Image result for technology monster In Wesch's article, "Anti-Teaching: Confronting the Crisis of Significance" he speaks about his experience with education and the concept he calls "Anti-Teaching". Wesch struggles with the idea of what teaching means versus what it has become. The education he compares anti-teaching to is one that I, and likely all of us, have experienced; large classrooms, neat rows and desks, and students asking "How long does this paper have to be?". Wesch argues that this form of teaching does not instill true learning that is significant to students, and simply teaches them how to pass arbitrary tests. In order to combat this, Wesch integrates as much connection into his classroom, both personally with his students and through technology. One of his projects involves students digitally creating a time-continuum of humanity that they show at the end of the semester. 

In regards to technology and connection in the classroom, I feel like these two authors are allies, in that they are both attempting to solve the issue of connection and significance in our society. While they are attempting to solve the same problem, they do not have the same viewpoint in regards to fixing this problem. Turkle argues that the solution to the problem is seemingly to avoid technology, removing it from spaces that should be technology free (certain rooms, offices or her trip to Cape Cod). On the other end of the debate, Wesch believes that we must learn to integrate these technologies in order to build connection. Rather than removing technology from his class, he has students embrace it and build connection through his projects or projecting screens onto the wall. Though drastically different solutions, both are working to build connection amongst our world and our students.

If I were to pick a side, I side with Wesch in this debate. Technology is not going to go anywhere, and metaphorically crawling under a rock (or Thoreau-ing it up in Cape Cod) will not teach our students how to use technology in a healthy way. In many debates, one side is often attempting to uphold the status quo, or the way things used to be. If we do not move forward and upset status quo, our society will stagnate. I think that if we were to think of ways to critically integrate technology into our lives in unique and meaningful ways, we can keep our classrooms and world progressively moving forward.

Image result for technology monster

Comments

  1. I like that you point out technology is not going to go anywhere, and metaphorically crawling under a rock (or Thoreau-ing it up in Cape Cod) will not teach our students how to use technology in a healthy way. As we learned in Boyd's article, that responsibility lies on today's teachers.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I love how you focused on her statement about being lonely. It is something I am very conscious of and working on as a model for my kids. I want them to be able to be alone! (especially so I can cook/clean etc...)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Thank you for taking the time to explain their differences in what either believes is the "solution" to the issue of connection! I agree that both Wesch and Turkle are allies, but what they propose is different. And I agree with you that of the two, Wesch seems more applicable/reasonable... while I do think taking a technology break is never a bad thing, to place such emphasis on it as to create whole spaces for it within existing structures, making it mandatory, is a bit much.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I loved your comment on how technology is not going anywhere. I actually just think that technology is finding new and better ways to integrate itself into our lives-- whether we like it or not. It makes me wonder what technology's role in our lives will be years from now and how it will impact our niches in the world... Hm.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Unlearning the Myths That Bind Us

While I was not a Disney obsessed child like some friends I had, I believe Disney played an important role in my childhood as source of entertainment and culture. I fondly remember watching many Disney classics such as Fox and the Hound or Robin Hood. As an adult, I primarily remember watching the movies that were unrelated to the princesses, likely because those were mostly directed towards typical female audiences. An exception that I recall would be the movie Mulan, which seemed more appealing as a child with its action and fighting. Additionally, I was fortunate enough to have been raised in San Diego, CA, which was only an hour away from Disneyland. Disneyland as an attraction was always a desirable location to go to, and one that was rare to attend as a family of 8. Regardless of background, everyone loved going to Disneyland if they had the means to do so. I also recall the 'playground status' given to students in elementary school that came back from vacations wea...

Quick Key Tutorial

One of the most important aspects of being a teacher is assessment. Assessments, whether formative or summative, are integral to effective teaching practices. As teachers, there are countless items on our To Do Lists, and often, the collection and analysis of classroom data is timely and easily neglected. Here to the rescue is Quick Key! Simply put, Quick Key is like the familiar Scantron test forms used throughout colleges. Unlike Scantron, Quick Key does not require any fancy forms (or even a number 2 pencil!), and as long as you have a smartphone, you are capable of quickly collecting and analyzing assessment data in your classroom. In order to get started, follow the short tutorial below! 1. Access the Quick Key website (or app on your phone). Click on "Teachers" on the homepage, and follow the "Sign up for Free" prompt. 2. Input the necessary personal information to create your account. The site offers 3 different account options, but you simply ne...